It was close and hard fought race but super hotty Jensen Ackles came out on top in the last few hours to play Talbot in our fantasy cast with 32 votes out of 88 (36%). Matt Lanter came in second with 24 votes (27%).
We only have 2 characters left to fantasy cast, and since I'm really mean I'm keeping Daniel under wraps until the very end. That means our next character to cast is:
Physical description: Dark brown hair like Grace's. She's half Italian/half Jewish. In her early forties.
Bridget Moynahan (Looks a lot like the Meredith Divine in my head)
Idina Menzel (Wonder if we could write in a scene where Mrs. Divine breaks into song?--j/k)
Julia Roberts (Would be great to see Julia Roberts playing the mother of Emma Roberts as Grace)
Kelly Preston (Has a nice motherly look to her)
Lauren Graham (Would be fun watching her go all neurotic)
Be sure to vote up over in the SIDEBAR poll and LEAVE A COMMENT to receive an entry to win 1 of 10 bottles of TLS nail polish. (You know you want it!) This poll will be open until 3:00 pm MST on Friday 11/5/2010.